Like millions of Americans, I once believed The Brady Bunch wasn’t just a sugary sitcom fantasy—it was a blueprint for how families should work. Polyester-clad harmony, avocado-colored kitchens, and life lessons that landed with the gentle thud of a sitcom laugh track. But why, decades later, does the Brady house at 11222 Dilling Street remain one of the most photographed homes in America? Why has the show’s popularity only exploded since its 1974 cancellation? And most baffling of all—why do people still worship at the altar of Sherwood Schwartz’s pastel-hued utopia?
In The Way We All Became the Brady Bunch, Kimberly Potts excavates this cultural phenomenon, tracing its roots to Schwartz’s other fantasy fiefdom—Gilligan’s Island. Both shows peddled the same delusion: you could toss together any group of mismatched personalities, and through teamwork, pluck, and a catchy theme song, everything would turn out just fine. In reality, unresolved resentment doesn’t dissolve neatly before a commercial break, and a shared kitchen doesn’t magically make step-siblings love each other. But Schwartz wasn’t interested in reality—he was selling optimism in Technicolor.
Sherwood Schwartz was America’s high priest of idealism, a man who saw divorce rates skyrocketing and decided to counterprogram with an unshakably cheerful alternative. His blended family would work, dammit, and they would thrive in a sun-drenched suburban utopia filled with pep talks and hugs. And I bought it. I was all in. From Captain Kangaroo reading The Little Engine That Could to Charles Atlas ads in comic books promising that a few reps with a dining chair could turn me into the next Hercules, I inhaled this belief system like it was the antidote to life’s inevitable disappointments.
And then came The Monkees.
October 16, 1967. The day irony smacked me in the face like a custard pie. I was five years old, watching the episode “I Was a 99-lb. Weakling”, blissfully unaware that my entire worldview was about to collapse. Micky Dolenz, my favorite Monkee, gets humiliated on the beach by Bulk, a Speedo-clad monument to muscle played by Mr. Universe Dave Draper. Worse, Bulk steals Brenda, the beach goddess, right out from under Micky’s drumstick-wielding hands.
Desperate to win her back, Micky joins Weaklings Anonymous. Their plan? Soul-crushing workouts and chugging fermented goat curd—a protein shake seemingly designed by the devil. He even sells his drum set to fund his transformation. The stakes couldn’t be higher.
And for what? Just as Micky nears his big, muscled-up revenge moment, Brenda has an epiphany—muscles are out. She ditches Bulk for a bookish intellectual reading Remembrance of Things Past. Apparently, Proust is sexier than pecs.
Sitting in front of my Zenith TV, I felt my faith in the universe disintegrate. The lesson was clear and soul-crushing: hard work guarantees nothing. You could sacrifice, sweat, and sip liquefied goat tragedy, only to have fate laugh in your face. The Monkees had broken me. I didn’t have the word for irony at age five, but I felt it snake into my bloodstream like a slow-acting poison.
Turns out, the Brady fantasy was a warm, comforting lie. The world wasn’t a sitcom. Sometimes, no matter how much goat curd you drink, Brenda’s just not into you.
Cinemorphosis 
Leave a comment