In the Black Mirror episode “Nosedive,” Lacie Pound carefully curates her public persona to climb the social ranking system, only to experience a spectacular breakdown when her performative identity collapses. Similarly, in the Netflix documentary Untold: The Liver King, Brian Johnson (aka the Liver King) constructs a hyper-masculine brand built on ancestral living and self-discipline, but his digital persona unravels after his steroid use is exposed—calling into question the authenticity of his entire identity.
Drawing on insights from The Social Dilemma and Sherry Turkle’s TED Talk “Connected, but alone?”, write an 8-paragraph essay analyzing how both Lacie Pound and the Liver King experience breakdowns caused by the pressure to perform a marketable self online. Consider how their stories reveal broader truths about the emotional and psychological toll of living in a world where self-worth is measured through digital validation.
Instructions:
Your essay should have a clear thesis and be structured as follows:
Paragraph 1 – Introduction
- Briefly introduce Lacie Pound and the Liver King as case studies in digital performance.
- State your thesis: What common psychological or social dynamic do their stories reveal about life in the attention economy?
Paragraph 2 – The Rise of the Performed Self
- Explain how Lacie and the Liver King construct public identities tailored for approval.
- Use The Social Dilemma and/or Turkle to support your claim about the pressures of online self-curation.
Paragraph 3 – The Collapse of Lacie Pound
- Analyze the arc of Lacie’s breakdown.
- Show how social scoring leads to isolation and emotional implosion.
Paragraph 4 – The Unmasking of the Liver King
- Describe how his confession undermines his brand.
- Discuss the role of digital audiences in both elevating and dismantling him.
Paragraph 5 – The Role of Tech Platforms
- How do algorithms and platforms reward performance and punish authenticity?
- Draw from The Social Dilemma for evidence.
Paragraph 6 – The Illusion of Connection
- Use Turkle’s TED Talk to explore how both characters are “connected, but alone.”
- Consider their emotional lives behind the digital façade.
Paragraph 7 – A Counterargument
- Could it be argued that both Lacie and the Liver King benefited from their online identities, at least temporarily?
- Briefly address and rebut this view.
Paragraph 8 – Conclusion
- Reaffirm your thesis.
- Reflect on what their stories warn us about the future of identity, performance, and mental health in the digital age.
Requirements:
- MLA format
- 4 sources minimum (episode, documentary, TED Talk, and one external article or scholarly source of your choice)
- Include a Works Cited page
Here are 7 ways Lacie Pound (Black Mirror: Nosedive) and the Liver King (Untold: The Liver King) were manipulated by social media into self-sabotage, drawn through the lens of The Social Dilemma and Sherry Turkle’s TED Talk “Connected, but alone?”:
1. They Mistook Validation for Connection
Turkle argues we’ve “sacrificed conversation for connection,” replacing real intimacy with digital approval.
- Lacie chases ratings instead of relationships, slowly alienating herself from authentic human bonds.
- The Liver King builds a global audience but admits to loneliness and insecurity beneath the performative bravado.
2. They Became Addicted to the Performance of Perfection
The Social Dilemma explains how platforms reward idealized personas, not authenticity.
- Lacie’s entire life becomes a curated highlight reel of fake smiles and forced gratitude.
- The Liver King obsessively maintains his primal-man image, even risking credibility and health to keep the illusion intact.
3. They Were Trapped in an Algorithmic Feedback Loop
Algorithms feed users what keeps them engaged—usually content that reinforces their current identity.
- Lacie’s feed reflects her desire to be liked, pushing her deeper into a phony aesthetic.
- The Liver King is incentivized to keep escalating his primal stunts—eating raw organs, screaming workouts—not because it’s healthy, but because it gets clicks.
4. They Confused Metrics with Meaning
The Social Dilemma reveals how “likes,” views, and follower counts hijack the brain’s reward system.
- Lacie sees her social score as a measure of human worth.
- The Liver King sees followers as a proxy for legacy and success—until the steroid scandal exposes the hollowness behind the numbers.
5. They Substituted Self-Reflection with Self-Branding
Turkle notes that in digital spaces, we “edit, delete, retouch” our lives. But that comes at the cost of honest self-understanding.
- Lacie never pauses to ask who she is outside the algorithm’s gaze.
- The Liver King becomes his own brand, losing sight of the person beneath the loincloth and beard.
6. They Were Driven by Fear of Being Forgotten
Both characters fear digital invisibility more than real-world failure.
- Lacie’s panic when her rating drops is existential; she’s no one without her score.
- The Liver King’s confession comes only after public exposure threatens his empire—because relevance, not truth, is the ultimate currency.
7. They Reached a Breaking Point in Private but Fell Apart in Public
The Social Dilemma highlights how tech is designed to capture our attention, not care for our well-being.
- Lacie breaks down in front of an audience, her worst moment recorded and shared.
- The Liver King’s undoing is broadcast to the same crowd that once idolized him—turning shame into spectacle.
Three Sample Thesis Statements
1. Basic (Clear & Focused):
Both Lacie Pound and the Liver King suffer emotional breakdowns because they become trapped by the very social media systems they believe will bring them success, as shown through their obsession with validation, performance, and visibility.
2. Intermediate (More Insightful):
Lacie Pound and the Liver King, though separated by fiction and reality, both represent victims of an attention economy that rewards curated identities over authentic living—ultimately leading them to sacrifice mental health, integrity, and human connection for the illusion of approval.
3. Advanced (Nuanced & Sophisticated):
As Lacie Pound and the Liver King spiral into public self-destruction, their stories expose the way digital platforms—backed by algorithmic manipulation and cultural hunger for spectacle—transform the self into a brand, connection into currency, and identity into a high-risk performance that inevitably collapses under its own artifice.









